## ProFTPD: Logging

Logging
Logging the activity of the server is an integral part of effective server administration. ProFTPD provides several different and flexing logging mechanisms. When examining the different logging mechanisms, have in mind the intended use of the logged data, the volume of data being logged, any post-processing that may need to be done, etc. Log files are more useful when they contain a complete record of server activity. It is often easier to simply post-process the log files to remove requests that you do not want to consider.

Security Warning
Anyone who can write to the directory where ProFTPD is writing a log file can almost certainly gain access to the UID that the server is started under, which is normally `root`. Do not give people write access to the directory where the logs are stored without being aware of the consequences: if the logs directory is writable (by a non-`root` user), someone could replace a log file with a symlink to some other system file, and then `root` might overwrite that file with arbitrary data. If the log files themselves are writable (by a non-`root` user), then someone may be able to overwrite the log itself with bogus data.

When opening log files, `proftpd` will by default log a warning if the file being opened for logging is in a directory that does not exist, or is world-writable. The log file will not be written in world-writable directories; there are no exceptions. (If you have configured log files in your `proftpd.conf` that are not appearing, check for the warnings about world-writable directories.) The `proftpd` process will also, by default, log a warning if the file given is a symlink; this symlink check can be configured via the `AllowLogSymlinks` directive.

In addition, log files may contain information supplied directly by the client, without escaping. Therefore, it is possible for malicious clients to insert control-characters in the log files, so care must be taken in dealing with raw logs.

Unix `syslog` Logging
By default, `proftpd` will log via `syslog(3)`, using the `daemon` facility (`auth` for some logging), at various levels: `err`, `notice`, `warn`, `info`, and `debug` (debugging is done at this syslog level). The location of the server's log files in this case is determined by your `/etc/syslog.conf` configuration.

You can fine-tune your `proftpd`'s syslog-based logging via the `SyslogFacility` and `SyslogLevel` directives. See the log level documentation for more details on these settings.

Log Files
There are three main types of logs that a `proftpd` daemon can generate: `TransferLog`, `SystemLog`, and `ExtendedLog`.

`TransferLog`
A `TransferLog` is the most common log kept, recording file transfers. It is written in the `xferlog(5)` format, described here, and in the `xferlog(5)` man page.

Each entry in the `TransferLog` is a single line of space-delimited fields:

Field | Values | Description
current-time | DDD MMM dd hh:mm:ss YYYY | Current local time at the time of transfer
transfer-time | Seconds | Total time in seconds for the transfer
remote-host | String | Remote client DNS name (or IP address)
file-size | Bytes | Number of bytes transferred
filename | String | Name of the transferred file
transfer-type | Flags | Indicates whether the transfer was an ASCII (`"a"`) or binary (`"b"`) transfer
special-action-flag | Flags | One or more single character indicating any special action taken: "C" (compressed), "U" (uncompressed), "T" (tarred), "_" (no action)
direction | Flags | Direction of the transfer: "o" (outgoing, i.e. download), "i" (incoming, i.e. upload), "d" (deleted)
access-mode | Flags | Method by which the user is logged in: "a" (anonymous), "g" (guest), "r" (real user)
username | String | Authenticated username
service-name | String | Name of the service used: "ftp", "sftp", "scp", etc
authentication-method | Flags | Method of authentication used: "0" (none), "1" (RFC 1413)
authenticated-user-id | Flags | Name of user provided by RFC 1413 lookup, otherwise "*"
completion-status | Flags | Single character indicating the status of the transfer: "c" (complete), "i" (incomplete)

History of the `xferlog(5)` Format
This xferlog(5) format seems a bit odd, right? To understand this, it helps to keep in mind the history of this format. The xferlog(5) format predates ProFTPD. The ProFTPD Project copied this format from wu-ftpd, which was the popular FTP server at that time. There were already existing tools/scripts which knew how to parse that format, so ProFTPD used it. Since then, `wu-ftpd` has waned in maintenance and popularity; other FTP servers (e.g. `pure-ftpd`, `vsftpd`, but not the built-in `ftpd` on FreeBSD) have since then picked up the `xferlog(5)` format from ProFTPD. Thus this log format has a 20+ year history, and keeps going.

This history helps explain certain fields in the `xferlog(5)` format, such as the authentication-method and authenticated-user-id fields. These fields were more relevant in the past, when the RFC 1413 Identd protocol was more widespread in use. Now, very few sites run `identd` servers; these fields in the log format are thus archaic. Thus in almost all ProFTPD-generated `TransferLog` entries, authentication-method will be "0", and authenticated-user-id will be "*".

Likewise, the special-action-flags field mentions "compressed" and "uncompressed" files; these flags specifically refer to the `compress` Unix program, which used the ".Z" file extension. This compression utility has been superceded with e.g. `gzip`, `bzip2`, and others these days. Thus the special-action-flags field in ProFTPD-generated `TransferLog` entries is almost always "_".

`SystemLog`
If the site administrator wants to have `proftpd` log its messages to a file rather than going through `syslogd`, the `SystemLog` configuration directive is the one to use. There is only one such file kept for the entire daemon. See the `ServerLog` directive for keeping a similar log on a per-vhost basis. Note that the `DebugLevel` directive only applies to `SystemLog` files; it does not materially affect the syslog-based logging messages.

`ExtendedLog`
The `ExtendedLog` directive is used to create log files of a very flexible and configurable format, and to have granular control over what is logged, and when. The format of an `ExtendedLog` is described using the LogFormat directive. Multiple `ExtendedLogs` can be configured, each with a different `LogFormat`.

Use of `syslog` versus file logging
Most sites will choose to have `proftpd` log via syslog (which is the default) or to a file (via the `SystemLog` directive). In either case, there is the question of logging verbosity, i.e. which messages to log. This verbosity is determined by the `SyslogLevel` directive. ProFTPD will log everything by default, meaning that the default `SyslogLevel` is effectively `debug`. If, however, you have your `proftpd` configured to log via syslog, then you should also check your `/etc/syslog.conf` file, to see what additional filtering of log messages is being applied by syslog. For example, if `/etc/syslog.conf` contained something like:

      # Log anything (except mail) of level info or higher.
      *.info;mail.none;authpriv.none;cron.none                /var/log/messages

then ProFTPD's log messages below the `info` level would be filtered out by syslog. When you are using syslog logging, the `SyslogLevel` configuration directive applies only to the proftpd logging, and does not control the additional syslog filtering.

For finer-grained control of the `debug` level log messages, ProFTPD internally implements different levels for its `debug` log messages. Currently ProFTPD has level 1 through level 10 `debug` messages. The `DebugLevel` directive is used control the verbosity/filtering of these messages. Since these different debug levels are purely a ProFTPD convention, the `DebugLevel` directive has no effect on syslog logging. Also, if your `SyslogLevel` configuration uses a level higher than `debug`, then the `DebugLevel` configuration will have no effect — your `debug` level messages are already filtered out by the `SyslogLevel` filtering.

The last point to mention is that the `SyslogFacility` directive only applies to syslog logging; it has no effect on file logging.

Log Analysis
There are a variety of log analyzers available; these are just a few:

- Webalizer: http://www.webalizer.org/
- HTTP-analyze: http://www.netstore.de/Supply/http-analyze/
- Analog: http://www.analog.cx/
- Report Magic: http://www.reportmagic.org/
- FTPWeblog: http://www.nihongo.org/snowhare/utilities/ftpweblog/

Log Rotation
On even a moderately busy server, the quantity of information stored in the log files is very large. It will consequently be necessary to periodically rotate the log files by moving or deleting the existing logs. This cannot be done while the server is running, because the daemon will continue writing to the old log file as long as it holds the file open. Instead, the server must be restarted after the log files are moved or deleted so that it will open new log files.

Another way to perform log rotation is using FIFOs as discussed in the next section.

FIFOs (a.k.a. named pipes)
ProFTPD is capable of writing log files to FIFOs, from which another process can read. Use of this capability dramatically increases the flexibility of logging, without adding code to the main server. In order to write logs to a pipe, simply create the FIFO at the desired path (`man mkfifo(1)`), and use that path in the logging configuration directive.

One important use of piped logs is to allow log rotation without having to restart the server. One such popular flexible log rotation program is cronolog; however, at present cronolog requires a small patch to enable it to read from a FIFO (by default, cronolog reads data from stdin). Please contact the author of this article for details concerning the patch.

Here's an example of FIFO-based logging script, based on one posted by Michael Renner:

      #!/usr/bin/perl

      use strict;

      use File::Basename qw(basename);
      use Sys::Syslog qw(:DEFAULT setlogsock);

      my $program = basename($0);

      my $fifo = '/var/log/proftpd-log.fifo';
      my $syslog_facility = 'daemon';
      my $syslog_level = 'info';

      open(FIFO, "< $fifo") or die "$program: unable to open $fifo: $!\n";

      setlogsock 'unix';

      openlog($program, 'pid', $syslog_facility);
      syslog($syslog_level, $_) while (<FIFO>);
      closelog();

      close(FIFO);
      exit 0;

More complex filtering can be added to such scripts.

If using FIFOs, there are some caveats to keep in mind. If you use in `init.d` script to start `standalone` daemons, you can add commands to start the FIFO logging programs first, before the daemon. For `inetd`-run servers, consider wrapping up the necessary commands for starting a FIFO reader and the server into a simple shell script, or simply run the FIFO-reading program from an `init.d` script, and save the overhead of starting that process, in addition to the `proftpd` process, for each FTP session.

FIFO-based log readers are a very powerful tool, but they should not be used where a simpler solution like off-line post-processing is available.

Note: In ProFTPD 1.3.3, the code was changed to use nonblocking `open(2)` system calls when opening log files. This was done to prevent a `proftpd` process from blocking indefinitely (i.e. "hanging") if the log file was a FIFO, and there was no FIFO reader process running when the log file was opened. However, some sites do want this blocking open behavior, as their FIFO reader processes may be temporarily busy. To get the pre-1.3.3 blocking behavior, you will need to compile proftpd using the `--disable-nonblocking-log-open` configure option.

SQL Logging
The `mod_sql` module also enables some powerful and complex logging capabilities...

Trace Logging
ProFTPD also supports a much more verbose form of logging called "trace logging". This form of logging is covered in greater detail here.

Pid File
On startup, `proftpd` saves the process ID of the parent daemon process to the file `var/proftpd/proftpd.pid`. This filename can be changed with the `PidFile` directive. The process ID (aka PID) is for use by the administrator in restarting and terminating the daemon by sending signals to the parent process. For more information see the stopping and starting page.

Scoreboard File
The last type of "logging" is done via the scoreboard file. The scoreboard is binary-formatted file the server uses to store information about each session; it is this file that is read by `ftptop`, `ftpwho` and `ftpcount`. The location for the scoreboard file is determined by the `ScoreboardFile` directive.

Frequently Asked Questions

Question: How can I direct the `TransferLog` logging to syslog?
Answer: It is not currently possible to configure proftpd to log `TransferLog` data to syslog. However, you can configure an `ExtendedLog` which logs to syslog, and which uses a `LogFormat` to log the data you wish. For example:

      LogFormat xfer "%h %l %u %t\"%r\" %s %b"
      ExtendedLog syslog:notice xfer

tells proftpd to log that `LogFormat` via syslog at the "notice" syslog level.

Question: I have `SystemLog` in my `proftpd.conf`, and when I use the `SyslogLevel` directive to try to filter the messages which `proftpd` logs to my `SystemLog`, it doesn't work. Why not?
Answer: When ProFTPD is configured to log everything to a file via the `SystemLog` directive, it will do just that: log everything, without any filtering, regardless of any `SyslogLevel` directive. However, this changed in ProFTPD 1.3.4rc1: in that release, the `SyslogLevel` directive was made to apply to file-based logging as well.

Question: I configured my `ExtendedLog` directive (or `SystemLog`, or other logs) to point to a FIFO. The FIFO path exists. But when I try to start `proftpd`, it fails to start with this error:

      unable to open ExtendedLog '/path/to/extlog.fifo': No such device or address

Shouldn't this work?
Answer: The "No such device or address" error occurs when you configure `proftpd` to log to a FIFO, and the FIFO reader process has not yet been started. In times past, `proftpd` would wait indefinitely on startup, waiting for the FIFO reader process to start; now, `proftpd` tries to open the FIFO in a nonblocking mode, so that it can fail immediately if there is no process on the other end of the FIFO.

The "fix" is to make sure that any FIFO reader processes are started before starting `proftpd`.

Question: How can I configure `proftpd` so that nothing is logged for certain clients/IP addresses?
Answer: Using a combination of classes and the `mod_ifsession` module, this can be done using a configuration like this:

      <Class invisible>
        From 1.2.3.4
      </Class>

      <IfClass invisible>
        # Disable all logging of these clients
        SystemLog none
        ExtendedLog /path/to/ext.log NONE
        TransferLog none
      </IfClass>

Question: How can I configure `proftpd` so that it does no logging at all? I have a very small embedded system for development/testing, and so do not need or want the logging.
Answer: To do this, you will need to disable much of the builtin, default logging that `proftpd` does, e.g.:

      # Discard the normal logging
      SystemLog none

      # Disable xferlog(5) logging
      TransferLog none

      # Disable logging to b/u/wtmp files
      WtmpLog off

In addition, you may need to go through your `proftpd.conf` file (as well as any `Include` config files), and remove all `ExtendedLog` and `TraceLog` directives. Also remove any per-module `*Log` directives like `BanLog`, `SFTPLog`, `SQLLogFile`, `TLSLog`, etc.

You might be tempted to symlink the log files configured to `/dev/null`, rather than changing the `proftpd.conf`. This approach can work, if you also use the `AllowLogSymlinks` directive, i.e.:

      # Allow proftpd to write logs to symlinks; note that this is insecure,
      # as the symlinks might be changed to point to other files such that
      # proftpd will overwrite them.
      AllowLogSymlinks on

Question: I see:

      wtmp /var/log/wtmp: No such file or directory

in my logs. What is `WtmpLog` logging? The description in the documentation is quite vague.
Answer: The `wtmp` logging support is not specific to `proftpd`, and instead is a more general Unix facility; this is why the ProFTPD documentation does not cover it in great detail. To learn more about `wtmp` (or any of its other incarnations: `wtmpx`, `utmp`, `utmpx`), please find their related man pages.

Now to make the "No such file or directory" log message go away, simply tell `proftpd` to stop trying to use `wtmp` logging by using the `WtmpLog` directive:

      WtmpLog off

in your `proftpd.conf`.

© Copyright 2017 The ProFTPD Project
All Rights Reserved